Introduction

Anne of Green Gables: The Continuing Story (2000) is the third installment in the beloved Anne of Green Gables television series, following Anne of Green Gables (1985) and Anne of Avonlea (1987). Unlike its predecessors, which were based on L.M. Montgomery’s novels, this film takes significant creative liberties, crafting an original wartime drama that follows Anne Shirley (Megan Follows) and Gilbert Blythe (Jonathan Crombie) into adulthood.

While the film retains the charm of its leads and the nostalgic beauty of Prince Edward Island, it diverges sharply from the source material, leading to mixed reactions from fans. This review explores the film’s strengths, weaknesses, and whether it holds up as a worthy continuation of Anne’s story.

Plot Summary (Spoiler-Free)

Set in the early 20th century during World War I, The Continuing Story follows Anne and Gilbert as they leave Avonlea for New York, where Anne pursues her writing career while Gilbert works in a hospital. Their lives take a dramatic turn when:

• Anne’s manuscript is stolen by a scheming publisher, leading her on a journey to reclaim her work.

• Gilbert is presumed dead after enlisting as a medic in war-torn Europe, forcing Anne to embark on a perilous quest to find him.

• Old friends reappear, including Diana Barry (Schuyler Grant) and Morgan Harris (Cameron Daddo), adding emotional depth to the story.

The film blends romance, adventure, and wartime drama, but its departure from Montgomery’s books has made it the most controversial entry in the series.

Strengths: What Works

1. Megan Follows & Jonathan Crombie’s Chemistry

The heart of the Anne of Green Gables series has always been the dynamic between Anne and Gilbert, and The Continuing Story delivers on that front. Follows and Crombie effortlessly slip back into their roles, portraying a mature, loving marriage that feels authentic. Their emotional reunion scene remains one of the film’s highlights.

2. Beautiful Cinematography & Setting

Despite much of the film taking place outside Avonlea, the visuals remain stunning. The lush landscapes of Prince Edward Island contrast with the grim war-torn European settings, reinforcing the film’s themes of home, love, and perseverance.

3. A Bold, Ambitious Narrative

Unlike the cozy, small-town charm of the first two films, The Continuing Story takes risks by plunging Anne into a wartime adventure. Some viewers appreciate this fresh take, as it explores Anne’s resilience in extreme circumstances.

Weaknesses: What Doesn’t Work

1. Major Departure from L.M. Montgomery’s Books

The biggest criticism is that the film completely abandons Montgomery’s original sequels (Anne of the Island, Anne’s House of Dreams, etc.). Instead of adapting Anne’s life as a mother and community figure, the film invents a melodramatic, almost soap-opera-like plot involving stolen manuscripts, espionage, and near-death experiences.

2. Pacing & Tonal Shifts

The first half (set in New York) feels rushed, while the second half (war drama) drags in places. The shift from lighthearted romance to heavy wartime tragedy is jarring, making the film feel uneven.

3. Underused Supporting Characters

Beloved characters like Marilla and Rachel Lynde are sidelined, and even Diana’s role is minimal. The new characters (like Morgan Harris) lack depth, making their arcs feel forced.

Themes & Emotional Impact

Despite its flaws, The Continuing Story explores meaningful themes:

• Love & Separation – Anne and Gilbert’s enduring bond is tested in heartbreaking ways.

• War’s Devastation – The film doesn’t shy away from depicting loss and trauma.

• The Power of Stories – Anne’s stolen manuscript symbolizes her voice being taken, but she fights to reclaim it.

Fans who grew up with Anne may find emotional resonance in her struggles, even if the execution is flawed.

Final Verdict: Is It Worth Watching?

For Die-Hard Anne Fans:

✅ If you love Megan Follows’ Anne and want closure for her and Gilbert, the film delivers emotional moments.
❌ If you’re a purist who wants a faithful adaptation, this will frustrate you.

For Casual Viewers:

✅ As a standalone wartime romance, it’s decently entertaining.
❌ The pacing and plot holes may test your patience.

Rating: 6.5/10

The Continuing Story is a flawed but heartfelt attempt to give Anne a grand, cinematic adventure. While it lacks the magic of the first two films, it still offers poignant moments for those invested in Anne and Gilbert’s love story.

Alternatives for a Better Anne Experience:

• Read L.M. Montgomery’s later books (Anne of the Island, Anne’s House of Dreams) for the real continuation of Anne’s story.

• Watch Anne of Green Gables: A New Beginning (2008) (though it’s also non-canonical).

• Try Anne with an E (2017-2019) for a grittier, more modern take.